| http://www.auburnjournal.com/articles/2005/07/07/news/top_stories/03pow.txt
Top Stories
POW
claim of Colfax VFW leader called fraud
Sultana stands by story now
denied by Pentagon
By: Carol Feineman, Gold Country News
Service
Thursday, July 7, 2005 12:05 AM
PDT
Graig
Sultana, who was quoted in a Colfax Record story last
week saying he was a prisoner of war, spoke falsely,
according to the Pentagon.
Sultana, 54, stands by his statements and is adamant he
was held prisoner in Laos during the Vietnam War.
The story was about Sultana being named the Veterans of
Foreign Wars of the United States' "Captain of the
All-State Commanders" and included several
paragraphs about his POW experiences.
The Colfax resident, who talked about being held in
captivity in Laos from 1970 to 1973, was never a
prisoner of war, said Larry Greer, Pentagon POW/MIA
office spokesman.
Sultana is commander of the Colfax Veterans of Foreign
Wars of the United States Post 2003 and also the Sierra
Vista Community Center's president, Colfax Planning
Commissioner, Colfax Veterans Memorial Building board of
trustee member and a Colfax Pride member.
In a Colfax Planning Commission application dated August
2003, Sultana lists himself as retired and formerly
working as an "investigative reporter" with
The Sacramento Bee. A human resources department
representative at The Bee said Friday, however, that
Sultana worked only in the circulation department during
the 1990s.
Sultana vehemently denied that he was
lying about his U.S. Armed Services record and said he
was forbidden to discuss details of his top-secret
mission.
"This is all hush-hush. I signed a thing with the
government not to go into this," Sultana said
Tuesday. "The Marines rescued me in 1971; they came
in on a special operation. I don't remember that stuff
about who rescued me or when."
Larry Greer, the Pentagon's POW/MIA office spokesman,
said Friday that any secret-mission explanation from
Sultana is unfounded.
"That's not the truth," Greer said.
"Officially, on behalf of the U.S. government,
there's no mission from the Vietnam War that he can't
talk about."
"Nobody by that name (Sultana) is listed in
governmental records that he was a POW," Greer
added. "This database includes names of people held
as POWS in Vietnam, those held in Laos, those held one
day, those held seven years. The list shows people who
worked for other agencies of the government, shows
civilians, missionaries, civilian contractors and the
military. It shows people on secret units in Laos.
There's nobody with a last name of Sultana."
The official U.S. governmental listing of Vietnam War
MIAs/POWs (which is on the Department of Defense's Web
site at www.dtic.mil/dpmo/pmsea/files.htm)
was compiled by U.S. units reporting daily on the
troops' status during the war, Greer said. Agencies such
as the CIA, State Department and non-governmental
organizations added the other names during the war.
"This listing has been challenged dozens of times
over the years and has never been proven inaccurate of
omitting names," Greer said.
The Sultana-POW controversy began when the Colfax Record
received an e-mail last Thursday from Retired Navy Capt.
Mike McGrath, a former Vietnam War prisoner of war,
stating that Sultana was a "POW wannabe."
A few hours later, Sultana unexpectedly called The
Record office and said "people out there will say I
never was a POW."
When asked last Thursday why someone would make such a
claim, Sultana replied that he "isn't supposed to
talk about the secret mission."
McGrath is past president and the current historian of
NAM-POWs, a nonprofit organization for the POWS of
Vietnam. Membership is open to only those who were POWs
in Vietnam. McGrath, who lives in Colorado, first heard
about Sultana four years ago when the POWNETWORK
contacted him.
Based out of Skidmore, Mo., the POWNETWORK records the
Vietnam POW history, according to the organization's
fraud investigator Mary Schantag.
Twelve hundred "POW wannabes" are listed on
the POWNETWORK's Web site at www.pownetwork.org/phonies/phonies.htm.
"We had several people since 2001 asking about
Sultana," Schantag commented. "They said,
'he's not listed on the (government's) POW list, can you
check him out?' They literally reported him because he
had been telling everyone he was a POW and was even
given special recognition by schools back in 2002."
"Sultana has been doing this for a long time. His
statements are all based on fiction," Schantag
said.
Schantag says her "wannabe" POW list (where
Sultana is listed as a fraud) is 100 percent accurate.
"For all those names up on our Web site, you have
to realize, should we be wrong, we can lose our home, we
can lose our nonprofit established in 1989 and we can
lose our reputation," she explained.
Since Schantag questions whether Sultana even served in
the U.S. Army, she has requested Sultana's military
records from the National Personal Records Center in St.
Louis, Mo. She expects to receive those public documents
within a month.
|
|
http://www.colfaxrecord.com/
You searched for: sultana
Military record: Sultana not a POW
Military records from the National Personnel Records Center
obtained this week verify that Graig Sultana, 54, was never a
Vietnam prisoner of war. On Friday, Sultana said he would talk
about the records on Monday. This Monday, Sultana said he had
"no...
4.7K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 1000.0
Military
record: Sultana not a POW
Military records from the National Personnel Records Center
obtained this week verify that Graig Sultana, 54, was never a
Vietnam prisoner of war. On Friday, Sultana said he would talk
about the records on Monday. This Monday, Sultana said he had
"no...
4.7K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 1000.0
Community
recognizes Graig Sultana's accomplishments
Local reaction to Graig Sultana making false claims about being a
Vietnam prisoner of war and wearing unearned military medals is
mixed. Wearing unearned military medals is a federal misdemeanor
that could result in fines and/or jail time. Although a...
4.6K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 790.0
Community
recognizes Graig Sultana's accomplishments
Local reaction to Graig Sultana making false claims about being a
Vietnam prisoner of war and wearing unearned military medals is
mixed. Wearing unearned military medals is a federal misdemeanor
that could result in fines and/or jail time. Although a...
4.6K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 790.0
Sultana's
claim of capture in Laos doesn't ring true
I am a Marine Corps Vietnam Veteran who served in the Marine Corps
from 1965 to 1971, and in Vietnam from January 1967 to February.
1968. 1 was in the 1968 TET offensive, just days before I returned
home. I have been a veteran advocate for over 30 ye...
1.9K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 730.0
Sultana's
claim of capture in Laos doesn't ring true
I am a Marine Corps Vietnam Veteran who served in the Marine Corps
from 1965 to 1971, and in Vietnam from January 1967 to February.
1968. 1 was in the 1968 TET offensive, just days before I returned
home. I have been a veteran advocate for over 30 ye...
1.9K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 730.0
Sultana's
claims about his captivity were preposterous
I read with interest the article of Thursday, June 30, 2005
"Saluting the New Captain." Concerning the claims of Mr.
Graig (Craig) Sultana, Mr. Sultana has been claiming for several
years that he was a Prisoner of War (POW) during the Vietnam War.
He...
6.6K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 695.0
Sultana's
claims about his captivity were preposterous
I read with interest the article of Thursday, June 30, 2005
"Saluting the New Captain." Concerning the claims of Mr.
Graig (Craig) Sultana, Mr. Sultana has been claiming for several
years that he was a Prisoner of War (POW) during the Vietnam War.
He...
6.6K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 695.0
Graig
Sultana a self-promoter
I don't belong to any veteran's groups, though I am in fact, a
veteran. I served in the U.S. Army 1974 to 77. Vietnam fell in
1975. That technically makes me a "Vietnam Era Veteran"
but I'll never say or do anything to lead anyone to think I went
to ...
2.0K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 547.0
Graig
Sultana a self-promoter
I don't belong to any veteran's groups, though I am in fact, a
veteran. I served in the U.S. Army 1974 to 77. Vietnam fell in
1975. That technically makes me a "Vietnam Era Veteran"
but I'll never say or do anything to lead anyone to think I went
to ...
2.0K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 547.0
Never
was POW, says Pentagon
Graig Sultana, who was quoted in a Colfax Record story last week
saying he was a prisoner of war, spoke falsely, according to the
Pentagon. Sultana, 54, stands by his statements and is adamant he
was held prisoner in Laos during the Vietnam War. The ...
8.6K - Jul. 7, 2005; scored 473.0
Never
was POW, says Pentagon
Graig Sultana, who was quoted in a Colfax Record story last week
saying he was a prisoner of war, spoke falsely, according to the
Pentagon. Sultana, 54, stands by his statements and is adamant he
was held prisoner in Laos during the Vietnam War. The ...
8.6K - Jul. 6, 2005; scored 473.0
Support
Sultana for the good he has done
I would like to express my disappointment in the (Colfax Record)
for making such a big deal about whether Graig Sultana is an
ex-POW or not. Wasn't he being honored for work he has done for
Veterans of Foreign Wars and other organizations in the last...
1.1K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 470.0
Support
Sultana for the good he has done
I would like to express my disappointment in the (Colfax Record)
for making such a big deal about whether Graig Sultana is an
ex-POW or not. Wasn't he being honored for work he has done for
Veterans of Foreign Wars and other organizations in the last...
1.1K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 470.0
Saluting
the new captain
For Graig Sultana, belonging to Colfax's Veterans of Foreign Wars
(VFW) of the United States has turned his life around. As for VFW
Posts throughout California, Sultana is a new role model. Last
week, Sultana received the all-state award or the "Capt...
3.8K - Jun. 29, 2005; scored 388.0
Public
invited to get involved with community center
For someone who retired five years ago
from the military to take it easy, Graig Sultana is
still doing a lot of running around. He's not only commander of
Jess E. Taylor Veterans of Foreign Wars Post 2003, a City of
Colfax planning commissioner and o...
3.0K - Jan. 27, 2005; scored 273.0
Vietnam
POW enjoys quiet life in Colfax
Craig Sultana left his Colfax home early Tuesday morning. As Sr.
Vice Commander of Colfax Post 2003 Veterans of Foreign Wars he
joined other VFW members in placing U.S. flags along downtown
streets. It But not too many years ago, Sultana would have b...
3.2K - Nov. 13, 2003; scored 256.0
Colfax
VFW Post 2003 installs new officers
Graig E. Sultana of Colfax recently took the reins as the post
commander of the local Veterans of Foreign Wars Jess E. Taylor
Post 2003. Sultana replaces outgoing Post Commander Harry Green.
Doug Brown of Woodland officiated the May 8 ceremony. Local...
1.4K - May. 20, 2004; scored 211.0
July
3 celebration is volunteers' reward of many weeks' work
With 29 Colfax Pride members spending a total of 1,100-plus
volunteer hours since April, members are looking forward to
spending 12 hours this Sunday in the downtown area. That day
validates the organization's mission, which is to sponsor the
Indepen...
4.8K - Jun. 30, 2005; scored 211.0
War
veterans discuss experiences
On Thursday, Oct. 28, three members of the Veterans of Foreign
Wars Jess E. Taylor Post 2003 were invited to Craig McAtee and
Becky Bianchis fourth-grade classes at Colfax Elementary School to
convey their ideas of patriotism. Herb Lyman, Ron Gersman...
2.5K - Nov. 4, 2004; scored 182.0
|
Wall
of Honor pays tribute to our vets
Most visitors - including the honorees - had left the Lot of Arts
Park Sunday by the time Colfax Pride volunteer Graig Sultana and Colfax Pride Chairman Ken Delfino officially dedicated the
"Wall of Honor," a temporary mural painted in honor of
Colfa...
2.9K - Jul. 7, 2005; scored 144.0
record
Roundup
Last Thursday morning, I awoke gasping for air, my nasal passages were completely clogged - dag nab it, the cold! I can't say which
is worse, a summer cold or a winter cold, because this cold
started while it was raining last week and ended in 80-deg...
.3K - May. 25, 2005; scored 144.0
Wall
of Honor pays tribute to our vets
Most visitors - including the honorees - had left the Lot of Arts
Park Sunday by the time Colfax Pride volunteer Graig Sultana and
Colfax Pride Chairman Ken Delfino officially dedicated the
"Wall of Honor," a temporary mural painted in honor of
Colfa...
2.9K - Jul. 6, 2005; scored 144.0
It's
hard finding out you can't believe everything
This is a good example that you can't believe everything you hear.
Case in point is my story last week about Graig Sultana receiving
the Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States' all-state
award, also known as the "Captain of the All-State Comma...
3.9K - Jul. 7, 2005; scored 91.0
In
honor of former naval aviators, this needs to be said
It is with great sorrow, but necessity that I pen this opinion.
The front page of last week's Colfax Record should have had
nothing but good news about the success of the Independence Day
weekend celebration put on by the volunteers of Colfax Pride, ...
4.9K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 91.0
Before
denouncing others, take a close look at yourself
Rocky Warren (letter to editor, Colfax Record, July 14) is proving
to all of us that there's a huge difference between a cop who goes
home to safety after the shift is over, versus a soldier whose
life is on the edge of death every minute of every da...
3.4K - Jul. 13, 2005; scored 91.0
In
honor of former naval aviators, this needs to be said
It is with great sorrow, but necessity that I pen this opinion.
The front page of last week's Colfax Record should have had
nothing but good news about the success of the Independence Day
weekend celebration put on by the volunteers of Colfax Pride, ...
4.9K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 91.0
Before
denouncing others, take a close look at yourself
Rocky Warren (letter to editor, Colfax Record, July 14) is proving
to all of us that there's a huge difference between a cop who goes
home to safety after the shift is over, versus a soldier whose
life is on the edge of death every minute of every da...
3.4K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 91.0
It's
hard finding out you can't believe everything
This is a good example that you can't believe everything you hear.
Case in point is my story last week about Graig Sultana receiving
the Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States' all-state
award, also known as the "Captain of the All-State Comma...
3.9K - Jul. 6, 2005; scored 91.0
VFW
installs new officers
The 2003-04 installation of officers for the Veterans of Foreign
Wars, Post 2003 and Ladies Auxiliary was held on May 24th.
Incoming VFW officers are: Commander Harry Green, Senior Vice
Commander Graig Sultana, Junior Vice Commander Robert Candler,
Q...
0.9K - Jun. 6, 2003; scored 91.0
http://www.colfaxrecord.com/articles/2005/07/21/news/top_stories/04graig.txt
Top Stories
Sultana's statements have divided the community
By: Carol Feineman,
Colfax Record Editor
Wednesday, July 20, 2005 8:00 PM
PDT
Graig Sultana's
statements the last three weeks that he was a prisoner
of war in Laos during the Vietnam War and that he was a
Sergeant First Class have divided members of volunteer
organizations he serves on, including Colfax Pride and
the Col-fax Planning Commission......
====================
http://www.colfaxrecord.com/opinion/letters/
Letters
Strange
how the records suddenly came to light
I have been agonizing over the
last couple of weeks on how to, or whether I should,
respond to the accusations that I was never a
prisoner of war during the Vietnam War. I'm damned
if I do and damned if I don't respond. I don't have any
proof. When I said, "I am fighting the
government," all that means is for the last 25
years I have been working very hard to get my real
records released and receive the benefits for which I am
entitled. I would gladly fight for my government again
if I were physically able to do so.
Never
a victory to expose fraud in veteran's ranks
I've read with great sadness all
the articles and commentary on Graig Sultana in today's
paper (July 14, Colfax Record).
Sultana
is doing great work for our veterans
I have been following the story
about Mr. Graig Sultana and must say I am rather
dismayed. Not because Mr. Sultana may have embellished
his military record 30 years ago, but because it has
become a witchhunt against a man who has been serving
his community and other veterans impeccably ever since.
Stories
of POW wannabes are all tiringly similar
Regarding the recent article
concerning Graig E. Sultana of Colfax who claims to have
been a POW held in Laos for two years. The stories of
POW Wannabes are so tiringly similar, "I was on a
secret mission..." "Even now I can't talk
about it..." How about, "I'm sworn to
secrecy..." Usually claimants say they were in
super secret Special Forces or SEAL units. Did you know
there are more wannabes out there than real returned
prisoners?
Sultana
should resign from all positions of trust
I believe it is time for the
leaders of Colfax and all other organizations that were
duped by Mr. Sultana to take the responsibility of a
first step to clarify his status. This step should
include a policy that Mr. Sultana is suspended from all
positions or duties in Colfax that have a requirement of
trust.
Sultana
has reasons for pride; he chose dishonor
Graig Sultana should be proud of
his service as a motor vehicle operator for the U.S.
Army's 196th Light Infantry Brigade in Vietnam, his
subsequent duty as a maintenance clerk in Sacramento and
Ft. Lewis, and his service as a senior heavy vehicle
driver in Germany.
Pattern
of lies behind Sultana's statements
I have had the opportunity to read
several of your paper's articles and letters to the
editor. All of them very interesting and well written. I
don't think I can add anything to the exposure that
already hasn't been said. While Mr. Sultana did serve in
the Army, we certainly give him credit for that. The
thing that I see here is a pattern of lies, such as
being a POW, serving in the Rangers, giving himself a
higher rank, etc.. With that, I find it difficult to
extend to him the trust and confidence required for his
various positions held on committees around town. It
also bothers me that the past commander of the local VFW
supports Mr. Sultana. I can only believe the membership
rolls will suffer as I would not desire to be a member
of an organization with a tainted leader.
Action
needed from Calif. State Commander
As a member of VFW, and a 100
percent service connected disabled Vietnam Veteran, I am
demanding that the California State Commander, and the
National Commander respond to this outrage by a person
who holds high office in VFW California and was recently
named "Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United
States "Captain of All-State Commanders." He
is commander of the Colfax VFW, Post 2003, among other
community titles. He is a disgrace to himself and the
VFW. If he goes unpunished for this outrage, I will
begin a national effort to recommend that all Vietnam
Veterans withdraw their membership from the VFW until
this fraud is prosecuted for his crimes.
State
Commander will take action to protect VFW
The VFW, Department of California
is aware of the issues as mentioned by David Prendergast
and I will assure you that our State Commander is
investigating this matter and will take the proper steps
to protect the VFW's image and reputation.
|
http://www.auburnjournal.com/
| You searched for: sultana |
Displaying
result(s) found.
|
Other
POWs, books say Sultana name not recognized
Stephen G. Long, who said he is one of seven POWs and three
civilians captured in Laos, flew missions from Thailand to Laos
for six months before being shot down on Feb. 28, 1969. Long was a
prisoner for 49 months until the war ended and the Paris Pe...
3.7K - Jul. 7, 2005; scored 1000.0
Colfax
divided over consequences for Sultana
Local reaction to Graig Sultana making false claims about being a
Vietnam prisoner of war and wearing unearned military medals is
mixed. Wearing unearned military medals is a federal misdemeanor
that could result in fines and/or jail time. Although a...
4.7K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 881.0
Support
Sultana for good he has done
I would like to express my disappointment in the Auburn Journal
for making such a big deal about whether Graig Sultana is an
ex-POW or not. Wasn't he being honored for work he has done for
Veterans of Foreign Wars and other organizations in the last ...
1.1K - Jul. 12, 2005; scored 525.0
Military
record: Colfax VFW head never a POW
Military records from the National Personnel Records Center
obtained this week verify that Graig Sultana, 54, was never a
Vietnam prisoner of war. On Friday, Sultana said he would talk
about the records on Monday. This Monday, Sultana said he had
"no...
4.4K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 461.0
POW
claim of Colfax VFW leader called fraud
Graig Sultana, who was quoted in a Colfax Record story last week
saying he was a prisoner of war, spoke falsely, according to the
Pentagon. Sultana, 54, stands by his statements and is adamant he
was held prisoner in Laos during the Vietnam War. The ...
5.0K - Jul. 7, 2005; scored 455.0
Wannabe
veterans need to be exposed
The story, in both the Colfax Record and Auburn Journal regarding
the lies of Graig Sultana, is an unfortunate mess for all sides.
Sultana is glib and pleasant. By all accounts a likeable and
energetic man. Unfortunately, he's a self-promoter, a frau...
3.1K - Jul. 12, 2005; scored 352.0
You
can t believe everything you hear
This is a good example that you can't believe everything you hear.
Case in point is my story in the Colfax Record last week about
Graig Sultana receiving the Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United
States' all-state award, also known as the "Captain o...
3.9K - Jul. 7, 2005; scored 101.0
Colfax
divided over consequences for Sultana
Local reaction to Graig Sultana making false claims
about being a Vietnam prisoner of war and wearing
unearned military medals is mixed. Wearing unearned
military medals is a federal misdemeanor that could
result in fines and/or jail time. Although a...
4.7K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 1000.0
Sultana
is doing great work for our veterans
I have been following the story about Mr. Graig Sultana
and must say I am rather dismayed. Not because Mr.
Sultana may have embellished his military record 30
years ago, but because it has become a witchhunt against
a man who has been serving his com...
1.7K - Jul. 17, 2005; scored 829.0
Support
Sultana for good he has done
I would like to express my disappointment in the Auburn
Journal for making such a big deal about whether Graig
Sultana is an ex-POW or not. Wasn't he being honored for
work he has done for Veterans of Foreign Wars and other
organizations in the last ...
1.1K - Jul. 12, 2005; scored 595.0
Military
record: Colfax VFW head never a POW
Military records from the National Personnel Records
Center obtained this week verify that Graig Sultana, 54,
was never a Vietnam prisoner of war. On Friday, Sultana
said he would talk about the records on Monday. This
Monday, Sultana said he had "no...
4.4K - Jul. 14, 2005; scored 523.0
Wannabe
veterans need to be exposed
The story, in both the Colfax Record and Auburn Journal
regarding the lies of Graig Sultana, is an unfortunate
mess for all sides. Sultana is glib and pleasant. By all
accounts a likeable and energetic man. Unfortunately,
he's a self-promoter, a frau...
.1K - Jul. 12, 2005; scored 399.0
Real
POWs should not be insulted by these fakes
I read with dismay the claims by Graig Sultana that he
was a POW in Vietnam, Journal, July 14. My father,
Howard Rutledge, Capt, U.S. Navy, deceased, spent 7
years as a POW in North Vietnam. The experience changed
not only his life but the lives of ...
0.6K - Jul. 17, 2005; scored 115.0
Speaking
on behalf of naval aviators
It is with great sorrow, but necessity that I pen this
opinion. The news from Colfax last week should have been
entirely good news about the success of the Independence
Day weekend celebration put on by the volunteers of
Colfax Pride, Inc. Yes there ...
4.8K - Jul. 17, 2005; scored 115.0
http://www.colfaxrecord.com/articles/2005/07/28/news/top_stories/05sultana.txt
Top Stories
Sultana resigns from planning commission, VFW and Colfax Pride
By: Carol Feineman, Colfax Record Editor
Wednesday, July 27, 2005 7:20 PM PDT
Graig
E. Sultana has resigned from three key positions in the Colfax
community. Sultana had "no comment" Tuesday...
---
http://www.colfaxrecord.com/articles/2005/07/28/opinion/letters/01rocky.txt
Sultana was decorated and deserves recognition
Wednesday, July 27, 2005 7:20 PM PDT
In the Colfax Record, (July 14),
Gordon Ainsleigh referred to me as a "knuckle dragger"
among other things. In the Auburn Journal (July 25) Larry Smith
referred to me as a "rah-rah" militarist, represented
himself as a peace advocate and then, incredibly, threatened to do
violence to me.
---
http://www.colfaxrecord.com/articles/2005/07/28/opinion/letters/02betty.txt
Letters
Leave Graig alone: Find another drum
Wednesday, July 27, 2005 7:20 PM PDT
I have been hoping all this
business over Graig Sultana would settle down and both the Colfax
Record and Auburn Journal would have some other news to report.
Apparently that is not the case.
After all the volunteering Graig has done for the city of Colfax,
and as commander of the local VFW, I find it hard to believe that
all anyone can think of him is the worst. He has nothing to gain
stating that he is a POW.
I read with interest his "Military Record" (Auburn
Journal and Colfax Record). The cover letter stated that this is
releasable information. This makes me think there must be some
non-releasable information, and as Graig has stated, he was on a
secret mission. As anyone knows, there are many acts our military
and our government do, and orders done, that "We the
People" never know about. Unless, however, they happen to get
caught!...
|