JOHN P DIETZ
|
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
|
By
Matt Baron, Special to the Tribune. Tribune staff reporter Russell
Working contributed to this report July
5, 2007 An
Oak Park man who had shared his story of perseverance in the face of
repeated tragedy was withdrawn as grand marshal of the village's 4th of
July parade after questions were raised about the truth of many elements
of his account. John
Dietz, 72, who continues to maintain that he is a decorated veteran, was
named grand marshal at the urging of Marianne Trifone,
a former Oak Park resident who now lives in Hoffman Estates. Trifone
said she had seen Dietz on Memorial Day and, after hearing his story,
contacted the Community Relations Commission subcommittee organizing the
4th of July parade to ask that he be honored. Chris
Jackson, chairman of the parade subcommittee, said Trifone
called him June 24, told him much of Dietz's story and asked that he
lead the parade. Jackson e-mailed information about Dietz to eight
people who serve with him on the subcommittee. None voiced an objection,
he said. About
4 p.m. Tuesday, Jackson said, Trifone called
to say that Dietz would not be at the parade. "There was not really
an explanation," Jackson said Wednesday. On
June 27, the weekly Wednesday Journal of Oak Park and River Forest ran a
front-page story with the headline "Leading the parade: John Dietz
has sacrificed more than most for his country." In
the story, Dietz claimed an extensive and well-decorated career in the
Marine Corps, including receiving three Purple Hearts. He shared a
horrific story of his wife and infant daughter perishing in a fire while
he was on his second tour of duty in Vietnam. And he mentioned his
playing on the University of Michigan football team before graduating
with an engineering degree. In
an interview Wednesday evening, with Trifone
by his side, Dietz maintained that the Wednesday Journal account was
accurate. Dietz,
who said he served in the Marines under the name John Diaz, said he was
not the one who decided to drop out of the parade, though he added that
he was not upset by the development. "I'm
just a bit confused and irritated at the whole matter, that it keeps
going on and on and on. ... I just prefer to be obscure," Dietz
said. Trifone,
when asked if she felt Dietz had been less than truthful about his life
story, replied, "There are some clarifications that need to be
made." She declined to comment on why Dietz was not in the parade. After
fielding an inquiry about Dietz from the Tribune on Monday, Doug
Sterner, an Army veteran and military historian from Pueblo, Colo.,
contacted other military historians. Within an hour, they were noting
discrepancies, including Dietz's claim that two of his brothers were
killed in Vietnam. Only one person named Dietz is reported to have been
killed in the war. Since
learning his last name may be Diaz, Sterner and his fellow historians
continue to find discrepancies, he said Wednesday. "Our
approach is to trust but verify," Sterner said. "It's a sad
situation that when we see veterans or someone who appears to be a
veteran, that there's a sense of suspicion about them." The
Tribune also contacted Marine officials earlier this week in an attempt
to verify Dietz's military service, but they said it would take a few
days to search their records. Officials at the University of Michigan
said they could find no record of him playing on the football team, and
they were searching other records to see if he attended the school. Dan
Haley, publisher of the Wednesday Journal, said Wednesday that he had
not read the story on Dietz before it ran. "I
know that there's an issue," Haley said. "We have a reporter
doing some reporting." About
three hours after the Tribune contacted Haley, the Wednesday Journal
posted an online update with the headline "Why Dietz didn't lead
the parade." The
newspaper said there was "confusion surrounding the veracity of key
details of his life story." Copyright
(c) 2007, Chicago Tribune |
|||||||||
| Records requested. | |||||||||