|
INTRODUCTION V V A - Claims by members of Vietnam Veterans of America ================================== |
Heroes or Villains? |
Individuals reported as
of 03/2008
Note: These individuals are IN ADDITION TO those investigated and named in the book STOLEN VALOR. Those
with a "LINK" have records, news articles, pictures or tales
posted |
THOSE CLAIMING MEDAL OF HONOR
|
||||
|
||||
M [2] |
||||
| Name | Date Reported | Hometown | Claims | Findings |
| McDaniel, Michael | . | in prison in Lovelady, TX |
Claiming RANGERS and... using identity of legit (now deceased) Ranger, bogus DD214 and bogus 201 file |
. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McDevitt, C.J. aka Charles J. McDevitt |
01/2001 10/2005 08/2006 08/2007 |
Maitland, Florida |
2001 - Checking on Chief (MTC) Charles J. McDevitt, Jr. Claimed to
be member of SEAL Team 2 with Vietnam service and later during Gulf
War reactivated with SEAL Team 6. After Vietnam left the SEALS and
was submariner. Retired in 1994. While Chief McDevitt was NJROTC
Instructor at Cypress Creek High School, Orlando, FL. Chief
McDevitt normally worn his SEAL pin along with his Dolphin pin
on his uniform. He has been removed by CNET from NJROTC duty
over the SEAL pin.
Chief McDevitt does have a DD214 which lists the SEAL pin in block
13 along with several other decorations, metals, etc. that he
is authorized to wear.
2006
.... went
to TSW International in Maitland, Florida today as a potential client.
I met with a CJ McDevitt, who told me right out of the chute that he
was a Navy SEAL. Upon returning home, I put “TSW International
Maitland” in my search window…and was led directly to your site. Interesting
to note he is still telling the same lies he told about a year ago, when you
posted him on your site. If he wasn’t aware of it before, he most
certainly is now.
CJ McDevitt wears a gold Navy SEAL emblem necklace boasting that he was a
SEAL for a brief time during Desert Storm. He claims to have been
seriously injured by a sea mine during an operation that went bad.
He said he laid in a military hospital for months recuperating from this
injury that almost killed him. When asked why he doesn't get injured
status or disability payments in his retirement, he says its because the
operation was so secretive that the records cannot be publicized as they
were somewhere they never should have been.
Despite his true service, commendations and efforts of serving the Navy,
he feels the need to elaborate his service and tell this huge tale to all
he comes in contact with. He uses this story to woo ladies and
deceive them into thinking he is of strong character and integrity when
all he is - is a charlatan.
unquote -------------------------------------------------------
|
10/13/2005 Please
note; as you are also aware, SEAL challenge coins can be purchased for as
little as $10 over the Internet, and a SEAL Trident “Budweiser” pin can
be purchased at virtually any military surplus store. Possession of those
items of SEAL paraphernalia don’t make a SEAL. Because
of the cost of training submariners, the Navy does NOT permit sailors who
are training for submarine duty or serving on submarines to apply for SEAL
training/duty. Men who wish to apply for SEAL training/duty must hold one of
a limited number of authorized source skill taskings/ratings. None of the
submarine ratings is included in that list. Steve
Robinson
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McDonald, Stan aka McDonald, Stanley J |
03/2005 | Fresno, Morro Bay CA |
Claims he had flown helicopters in the war and mentioned some
of his flying experiences. Claims that he hadn’t gone through flight
school, but as a supply officer he was in a unit that was short of
helicopter pilots and they taught him how to fly.
http://www.fresnobee.com/local/story/10126171p-10948823c.html .... He crowed, "I'm off to play." The former military helicopter pilot plans to finish building a gyro-copter and fly it to air shows. .... |
"In any case, he did not fly
helicopters in Vietnam"
VHPA =================== Name STANLEY J MCDONALD 81150 Security Policeman |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McDougald, Nathan Ellis | . | . | CLAIMING SON TAY RAID PARTICIPATION | . | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McDowell,
Robert Gill
|
. | 2004 2005 at it again 2006 still at it 04/2007 10/2007 |
QUESTION EVERYTHING !!! 04/2007 Still at the University of New England where he teaches Biology, Anatomy as well as Forensic science (and possibly others), and has claimed affiliation with the FBI, as well as the CIA in class. When he tells stories of his military life in class, they never seemed to add up and many seemed fictitious. He claims direct connection to the Terry Schiavo autopsy among being part of every branch of military that exists. He has also claimed to possess superhuman immunities to terminal illnesses (has contracted malaria twice, etc...). He has told many stories that correlate with the ones on the website, and is still claiming to be a POW
02/2006 at it again
02/2005
2005 - McDowell surfaced in Nashua,
New Hampshire.
Amazingly, the high school principal who hired
McDowell says McDowell's resignation is the only sanction he'll
receive, because "he's been through enough."
2004 - McDowell scammed the Yeshiva of Greater Washington DC, claiming degrees he didn't have and military service he didn't perform to get hired as a teacher. 2007:
quote
Robert G.
McDowell is a retired high school educator, current
university professor, and a 30 year veteran of the United States
Naval Reserves and United States Marine Corps. His military
expertise includes counterterrorism,
explosives ordnance disposal, coastal defense, and
operational oceanography. He is a certified diver. His
civilian expertise includes public school administration, teaching
the sciences to secondary and post-secondary students, and forensic
pathology. He has managed and developed numerous skill based
educational programs such as High-Adventure training programs, and
has led students in a variety of non-traditional field experience
training and coaching programs. He has been recognized on
numerous occasions for outstanding commitment to education in areas
of science and leadership. His primary current interest is
local government response to the unique natural disaster and
terrorism threats to local governments along coastlines, rivers, and
lakes, as well as volunteer involvement and management in disaster.
Rob holds undergraduate degrees in biology,
marine biology, and science eduation, and a Ph D in
education. He teaches anatomy and physiology and
pathophysioloty to medical students and other allied health
professionals in the post-secondary eduational system.
end quote
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McGuinn, Louis Lowell |
NY |
11/2006 05/2007 |
http://www.msnbc.msn.com:80/id/18414118/
Feds: Man Lied About Silver Cross, Silver Star
Medals The FBI arrested Louis Lowell McGuinn on charges he wore medals on his uniform he never earned including the Purple Heart, Distinguished Silver Cross Cross and Silver Star. Investigators said he also lied to employers that he was a former Lieutenant Colonel with the Special Forces in order to gain security consulting positions. Federal prosecutors said McGuinn, 62, served as a private in the military and that the wearing of unearned medals is a violation of federal law punishable of up to a year in prison. Investigators said McGuinn was seen wearing the medals at a ceremony at the Merchant Marine Academy in Kings Point when an official there noticed he was wearing his uniform decorations incorrectly. McGuinn pleaded not guilty and was released on $5,000 bail after his arraignment in federal court in Manhattan. http://www.wnbc.com/news/13229192/detail.html http://www.nydailynews.com/news/2007/05/01/2007-05-01_vet_medals_tarnished http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime_file/2007/05/02/2007-05-02_vet_more_like_special_farce.html http://www.queenscourier.com/articles/2007/05/04/news/news03.txt
McGuinn served in the Army for a short period of time. He was discharged an E2. MOS was 11C. =========================================== Community service for soldier with phony medals who posed as war hero Thursday, April 3rd 2008, 4:00 AM A soldier who pinned phony medals on his uniform in a sham display of valor was sentenced to 100 hours of community service Wednesday by a judge who blasted him for dishonoring real heroes. Louis McGuinn, 59, became one of the first accused fakers sentenced under the federal Stolen Valor Act, which makes it a crime punishable by a year behind bars to pose as a war hero. "I beg the court's forgiveness," McGuinn told Manhattan Magistrate Judge Kevin Fox. "I realize now that I did something wrong. This has been a tremendous hardship on myself, my family, my friends, employment." McGuinn, of Flushing, Queens, pleaded guilty in December to wearing the Distinguished Service Cross, Silver Star and several Purple Hearts and claiming to be a retired lieutenant colonel. McGuinn was discharged from the Army in 1968 as a private. McGuinn's ruse was revealed when an eagle-eyed vet became suspicious after meeting him at a military gala at The Pierre hotel in Manhattan. A photo of McGuinn, with medals on his chest, eventually landed in the Washington offices of the FBI unit that tracks phony war heroes. McGuinn must also serve a year's probation. |
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
CONTACT: U.S. ATTORNEY’S OFFICE
April 30, 2007
YUSILL SCRIBNER,REBEKAH CARMICHAEL PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICE (212) 637-2600 FBI NEIL DONOVAN, JIM MARGOLIN (212) 384-2715, 2720
MAN ARRESTED FOR WEARING UNEARNED SERVICE MEDALS AND BADGES,
INCLUDING SILVER CROSS, PURPLE HEART, AND SILVER STAR
MICHAEL J. GARCIA, the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, and MARK J. MERSHON, the Assistant Director-in-Charge of the New York Office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI"), announced that LOUIS LOWELL McGUINN, a/k/a "Lowell Craig McGuinn," was arrested today by agents of the FBI for wearing service medals and badges, including the silver cross, purple heart, and silver star, that he did not earn. According to the Complaint filed in Manhattan federal court: McGUINN, who was discharged from the armed service in 1968 as a private, stated that he changed his name and date of birth to reinvent himself and provide himself with maturity when applying for employment. In addition, he informed at least one security company that he was a Lieutenant Colonel attached to the Special Forces in order to obtain employment with them as a security consultant. Later, in December, 2006, he similarly told a New York Police Officer that he was a Lieutenant Colonel, and further stated that he was currently working with Homeland Security as an outside contractor and was involved with the Latin American Carribean Security Council. As part of his ruse, MCGUINN wore numerous medals and badges on his uniform without authorization, including a Purple Heart, Silver Star, and Distinguished Service Cross, among others, in violation of 18 U.S.C. 704(a) & (d). McGUINN was observed wearing the medals at social functions, including an event at the United States Merchant Marine Academy in Kings Point, Long Island, where the Executive Director of the Soldiers, Sailors, Marines & Airmen Club noticed that McGUINN wore decorations on his uniform in the incorrect manner. McGUINN was photographed wearing the medals to a social event at the Pierre Hotel in Manhattan. McGUINN faces a maximum sentence of one year in prison, among other possible penalties. Mr. GARCIA praised the investigative work of the FBI and the Department of the Army Criminal Investigation Division. Assistant United States Attorney Michael M. Rosensaft is in charge of the prosecution. The charges and allegations contained in the Complaint are merely accusations and the defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. 07-105 ###
===========================
Vietnam vet pleads guilty to posing as a war hero
7:19 AM EST, December 13, 2007 NEW YORK - A Vietnam veteran who posed as a war hero has pleaded
guilty to wearing several medals that he never earned. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McKay,
Peter A aka Peter Ellis aka Patrick David Ellis aka Michael Ellis |
Fresno. Lindsay, Porterville CA Formerly of San Antonio, TX |
05/2005
|
"Actually
I can identify...I did four tours in three different theatres. I was a
combat medic so include a collapsing litter, trauma bag and field set up
you can add another 25 lbs to that. I never carried the AT4, I trained
on it but the LAW was better IMHO. I only carried the pig once, in an
exercise in Texas during the hottest summer Lubbock has ever seen. But
being an officer I only carried it to the nearest enlisted man, or about
1/2 a mile.
"Only the guilty crys his innocence the
loudest" -Ben Frankiln
|
Records were requested under: Peter A McKay and sent "Patrick David Ellis (Name shown on Record)" Served Oct 16, 1978 to Feb 8 1979. Private Transcript of Court Martial not in file. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McKay, William Sanford | . | . | Claiming SEALS and/or
Frogman... Airborne Range, shot, woke up in Japan as SEAL, CIA, "Virginia Boy" |
. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McKeaque, William L. | 5 decades of lies | Riverside CA | Riverside National Cemetery, dedication of the Veterans Memorial Saturday 25 May 2002 | . | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McKelvey, Albert T. | 01/2006 | PA | http://pittsburghlive.com/x/tribune-review/trib/regional/s_416847.html
Pittsburgh Tribune-Review -
Pittsburgh,PA,USA TRIBUNE-REVIEW Wednesday, January 25, 2006 |
. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McKenzie, Cooper | 05/2007 | . | http://www.wdam.com/Global/story.asp?S=6582762
Funeral services will be held Wednesday for a highly decorated Jones County WWII veteran. Cooper McKenzie served with the 100 First Screaming Eagles Airborne Division during WWII and was awarded two purple hearts and the Medal of Honor. He was also a POW during the war. Visitation will be held Tuesday night from 5-8pm at Memory Chapel Funeral Home in Laurel with funeral services Wednesday at 10am at Memory Chapel. Cooper McKenzie was 85 years old. |
. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McMillian (McMillan) Donald | . | . | Claiming SEALS and/or Frogman... | . | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McMillian, John Andrews Jr. | 11/2006 | FL | Wears Marine Gunny Sgt stripes on his
hat and says he has 5 Purple Hearts from Vietnam. |
Discharged a private, never in Vietnam. AWOL - 4 months confinement. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| McWhorter, Wendell Fay | 02/2007 | . | http://www.legacy.com/saltlaketribune/Obituaries.asp?Page=Lifestory&PersonId=86568562 Wendell Fay McWhorter Gone Fishin' 11/10/1924~2/20/2007 Our loving father, grandfather and great-grandfather returned to his Heavenly Father, Feb. 20, 2007. He was born Nov. 10, 1924 to Fay Edward McWhorter and Mabel Carver in Treasureton, Idaho. He married Thelma LaRue Butcher, Oct. 22, 1948, in Salt Lake City; later divorced. Married Helen Ann Hess in 1970. Decorated World War II. He fought in Okinawa and Guatal Canal; Presidential Medal of Honor. He worked as a molder at American Foundry, Union President for Lundy &Mayne for umpteen years, also worked for and retired from the US Post Office and Sutherlands. Wendell "Breezy" enjoyed fishing, deer hunting, camping, gardening, his beautiful roses, and spending time with his family. We will miss his guitar playing and wonderful voice. ... |
. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Mejia, Rudy
Rudy Schwartz Mejia is now going only by the name Rudy Schwartz |
08/2002 01/2003 2005 08/2006 |
CA | Claims Somalia Ranger,
POW, works at VA in Los Angeles. Medals claims include scuba
bubble, combat jump wings, air assault, pathfinder and Ranger Tab,
with E5 rank. Claims jumped into Panama. Rangers say NO WAY.
Actually, they said "this guy should he hung by his
toes....." pictured in American Legion Magazine as former
POW. When confronted by Rangers in 01/2003, jumped from 2nd story window into BBQ pit. Injured, not seriously. 02-2003 - Claiming Medal of Honor - soliciting donations. |
REAL
RECORDS and more |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Melendez,
Edwin (NMN)
aka EDDIE MELENDEZ, CSM, RAINBOW SIX
|
again 02/2005 again 02/2006 again 07/2006 again 05/2007 |
dozen addresses since 1992 in New York and Florida. Latest is Orlando, FL | Claims
to have attended and been awarded and Ranger School and Tab in 1986. Claims service with 1SFOD-D from 1990-96, 7th SFG in El Salvador. spooke10@excite.com He claimed to be in the Miami VA Hospital's 14 Day PTSD program in
March. (claims for disability compensation, based on his also
claimed PTSD due to all the black ops he was on in El Salvador)
He admitted to having been in the joint
for nearly two years during the nineties, while simultaneously
claiming not to have been discharged until 2002.
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Mercado, Louis G | 10/2007 | NYC | Arrived
in country as a E-6 and left service as a SgtMaj. He as a picture in the
C Co. 1st Bn 4th Marines web site
http://www.3rdmarines.net/3rd_Marines_Roster_L_Z.htm
|
Only possible match
on military.com
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Mercer, Charles Danny | 09/2005
05/2007 03/2008 |
Lisbon, OH | Claims
Green Beret for two tours in Vietnam. Another instance stated "
Five months S.F."
---------------------------------
|
WAS
in Vietnam, was NOT Special Forces. Served Jan 69- March 71. Discharged
a PFC
12A10 |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Metzger, Robert D. | 2001 | AL | VVA MEMBER Claims Medal of Honor | . | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Meyer, Keith L. | 10/2005 | MN | http://www.grandrapids-mn.com/placed/Obits.php?obit_id_ ser=52941&date=2005-10-02 Keith L. Meyer, , Keith L. Meyer, Marine on St. Croix, formerly of Bigfork, passed away peacefully with family members at his side on Tuesday, Sept. 27, 2005, at Fairview-Wyoming Medical Center, Wyoming, Minn. He was born in Wadena on Nov. 20, 1930 to Eldred and Norma Meyer. He served in the U.S. Air Force for 21 years, including the Korean War and Vietnam War, where later he had earned the Congressional Medal of Honor award. After his retirement from the service, he drove school bus for the Bigfork School District and had worked in the mines. He was a member of Swampsiders Snowmobile Club...... |
If you go to
the following Official Medal of Honor Recipient Website, you will find
his name is NOT listed.
http://www.army.mil/cmh-pg/moh1.htm
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Meyers, Dennis, aka Myers, Dennis |
. | Flagstaff, AZ | Claiming SEALS and/or
Frogman...
Seal Team 6, Laos, SOG |
. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Michaud, Edward Richard aka Michaud, Edward aka Michaud, Edrward R. |
. | Massachusetts | Claiming SEALS
and/or Frogman...
Dob 1/57 ========================================== http://www.subsearesearch.com/contact.htm
Edward Michaud – Senior Researcher http://news.bigg.net/n8527-Richest_Treasure_Ever_Lost_Found.html
Richest
Treasure Ever Lost - Found in
the website http://blog.myspace.com/
Go to http://blog.myspace.com/shiprex1 Greg
Brooks and others of Sub Sea Research have more dramatic personal and
detailed accounts of their salvage exploits going to Haiti and a story of
kidnapping and murder. And a story of their diving boat sinking at the pier
in Florida and hassles with the marina's owner etc. etc. The stories on
myspace.com are a bit more wild and far-out. Basically it gives investors
interesting stories for their financial investments. At the end of this URL
there is Michaud's incredible story of the U-boat with hitler's gold. This
was posted 7 JUL 06.
Underwater
explorers who’ve examined the wreck say their research indicates that
it’s the Notre Dame de Deliverance — a 166-foot, armed merchant vessel
of French origin. The research includes surveys of the site by
state-of-the-art remote sensing devices, ROV’s and divers, a study of
historical records, and the discovery that a few silver items — including
a crucifix, plate and some coins — were brought up years ago by other
salvagers. recent underwater video footage is now being analyzed to
determine the best procedure for recovery. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| MICHNIEWICZ, MICHAEL A | 03/2008 | Philadelphia
PA |
Mr. Michniewicz can
be seen here wearing a captains rank on his hat. http://i216.photobucket.com/albums/cc263/56456tass702/Argent009/argentspartast0.jpg The still is from a video that was later deleted. The "character" in the background was super imposed. This is one of Mr. Michniewicz's "channels" were he posts videos. http://www.livevideo.com/argent009 In one of his video comment sections. Mr. Michniewicz comments on how he had to "buy" his medals on ebay because his medals were stolen. http://www.livevideo.com/media/commentmedia.aspx?cid=811FBB5E28674F0CA10CF4AE39012183 This is a still from that page showing the conversation where Mr. Michniewicz makes the claim. http://i216.photobucket.com/albums/cc263/56456tass702/Argent009/Image2.jpg |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Miller, Christopher Ralph | . | Santa Rosa, CA | Claiming SEALS and/or
Frogman...
Attorney - Claims Navy SEAL |
Actual electronics training at Treasure Island - 18 months service. Dob Aug 44, 5'10", 180 lbs | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Miller, Paul J | MO Cemetery | 12/2005 |
|
Bottom Line engraved: Medal of Honor
Shain Memorial Cemetery Butler, MO |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Miller, Steve | . | Litchfield Pk. AZ | thrown out of Civil Air Patrol , AZ Wing, cadet program for misrepresentations. Claims USMC, Purple Heart, kevlar leg, shrapnel wounds, wears Col's uniform. | . | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Milne, Michael
Foster aka "Phoenix" |
08/2005 | Wilkes-Barr PA |
Claimed Army Ranger Lt with 173rd; 3 Purple Hearts; member of covert Phoenix and SOG Programs |
Spec 5, Sr. Engr
Mechanic with 541 Engr Co and Co A 36th Engr Bn, and 94th Engr Det. NO Purple Heart, no awards of "Valor" |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Mitchell,
Robert aka BK Mitchell |
again and again
and again
11./2005 |
Oregon in 2005 |
CLAIMING AFGHAN WAR STATUS 2008 is now living in Traverse City MI - claims that he is Indian shaman, and navy SEAL, special forces, poetry writer click his name |
. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Mizelle, Arcie Gray aka Dr. Arcie G Mizelle aka Arcie G Mizelle N.D., Ph.D.
|
09/2004 | Statesboro, GA | Claims 5th Group (Bragg)
Special Forces highly decorated NCO, Medic, Naturopathic physician, and
PhD.
Has been seen in a COAST GUARD uniform. Has a Russian wife. |
QUESTION EVERYTHING !!!42 addresses last 20 yrs. Married before being divorced. Filed bankruptcy to avoid paying judgment of $375,000.00. Restraining orders; arrest pending for Class B Felony, Theft of service; Federal Tax Lien; Warrant - Failure to appear, Theft by check AND MORE.Army 1973- 1981 No degree ever issued from
Brewton-Parker College. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Monarski, Edward John | 02/2005 | Syracuse New York | Claims
USMC, Korea. Claims commander of Korean War Veterans International Inc. Forged a DD214 to show service in Korea.
|
".......Dropped
from membership roles of the Korean War Veterans Assoc national
organization, New York State department and the local Central New York
chapter because he was never ( on active duty) in the Armed
Forces during the Korean War...."
excerpted from the Post Standard, editorial by Dick Case. DONORS BEWARE......... Reportedly barred from all NY VFW posts. Keeps attempting to raise funds for "phone cards" for wounded vets. When told one host business would write the check for the amount collected.... Monarski cancelled the fundraiser rather than allow the host to have any oversight as to monies collected by Monarski. ======================================= Subject: Death of
one of the frauds listed on your website
This is to inform you
that Edward Monarski, Syracuse, NY, died a few weeks age. He
appears to have been a fraud to the end, as it is my understanding
that he appeared at the Syracuse Veterans Hospital requesting
treatment, but died before getting any medical help. Never
served a day on active duty, National Guard member who was never
activated, and organized Central NY Chapter of the Korean War with
fraudulent DD214 claiming service as Marine in Korea during
that war.
A V Past Commander, CNY Korean War Veterans Association |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Moneymaker, Randall A. | 10/2007 03/2008 |
VA |
http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=4531088&page=1 Don't miss the extra links to others exposed on this blog page! ========================
Former
soldier accused of lies Former soldier accused of lies
By Laurence Hammack |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Montagna,
Ronald Paul aka Ronald Paul Alexander aka Ron Montana aka Ronnie Montana |
08/2007
01/2008 |
. |
=========================================================================== ...If the
name you provided is spelled correctly, I do NOT find a listing in the
SEAL database for anyone named RONALD
PAUL MONTAGNA. Be aware that I have also examined
possible alternate spellings, and names with similar pronunciations,
but found none that were even close. Unless he has undertaken the unlikely action of a legal name change (an action for which there would be court documentation) since his claimed service with the SEAL Teams, and based upon the information you have provided, I can state conclusively that RONALD PAUL MONTAGNA has NEVER completed UDT/SEAL training, and he is not now, nor was he ever a US Navy SEAL or UDT “Frogman”. Please be aware that the SEAL database includes the names of all men who served with the Underwater Demolition Teams (“Frogmen”). Since 1983 when the UDTs were all re-commissioned as SEAL Teams it has been the convention within the Naval Special Warfare community to use the modern term “SEAL” when referring to all men who ever served in any of the SEAL ‘precursor’ units. ... The only men
who can legitimately call themselves SEALs are US Navy sailors who have
completed the entire SEAL training program which lasts approximately 2
years and who have received a formal/official designation as
“Combatant Swimmer [SEAL]” with an attendant entry in their military
records of a specific 4-digit Naval Enlisted Classification (NEC) Code. It is quite
common for those making fraudulent SEAL claims to cite a “secret”
training class, “special selection and skills which allowed them to
bypass BUD/S training”, or “secret missions” as an explanation for
the lack of military documentation to back up their stories. SEAL
imposters also tend to claim their military records are “sealed” and
cannot be accessed. Occasionally inventive imposters claim their records
were destroyed in a fire at the I might
suggest that you also ask Mr. MONTAGNA
to specifically identify WHICH SEAL Team(s) he served on,
and when. The generic term “Group 2” offered by Mr. MONTAGNA
is meaningless. It should be noted that specific historical Team
assignments are not classified in any way. I am in direct
contact with several hundred of my SEAL Teammates whose collective
experience covers virtually all time periods from the Korean War to the
present; I can quickly contact those individuals to verify any specific
names, events, or other claims offered by Mr. MONTAGNA.
If he feels that his name has somehow been mistakenly omitted from the
SEAL records, I’d be pleased to speak with him and hear details of his
service which would serve to validate his claims. The Director of the
Naval Special Warfare Archives – a close personal friend and SEAL
Teammate – is only a phone call away and standing by to amend the
records if this is ever found to be true. However, I’ve made the same
offer to more than 3,600 SEAL imposters in the last five years, and none
of them ever turned out to be a valid SEAL. If Mr. MONTAGNA
subsequently suggests to you or others you know that he has contacted
me, the Department of the Navy, or “the government” in some way and
“straightened things out”, I’d be very interested in hearing from
you again. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s claims
of being involved in a POW Exchange are preposterous and I can assure
you that no such action/exchange took place. Please contact the POW
Network (info@pownetwork.org)
for confirmation of this fact. I am taking the liberty of sending them a
copy of this message so that they might be prepared for any inquiries
you send their way. They will also provide you with absolute
verification of the following statement: “NO
UDT “FROGMAN” OR US NAVY SEAL HAS EVER BEEN CAPTURED, DETAINED, OR
HELD AS A PRISONER OF WAR… NEVER!” Mr.
MONTAGNA’s claims
of being administered narcotics or drugs of any kind during any portion
of SEAL training are absolutely without merit. In accordance with US
Navy policy the use of any such substances is sufficient to immediately
terminate a man’s continued training or service with/for the SEAL
Teams. To claim that the NAVY would violate its own policies by
administering such chemical compounds is patently ridiculous. His
further claim that the administration of drugs/narcotics was done in an
effort to prepare him for capture and to evaluate his possible
weaknesses to those drugs under such stressful conditions is absurd in
the extreme. SEALs undergo survival training AFTER they complete SEAL
training, and a portion of that survival course involves exposure to a
mock POW camp. That course is known as SERE (Survival Escape Resistance
Evasion) School. The exercise difficulties that are experienced during
that exercise are entirely physical and mental, and no drugs are ever
administered. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s claims of
parachuting into an arctic wilderness and undergoing a survival test are
‘generic’ at best and such descriptions may be applied to virtually
any survival training or testing techniques as conducted by the US
military in general. His statements do not reveal any inside or
‘special’ knowledge nor offer any proof or substantial evidence of
his participation in any such training or testing. While all SEALs are
put through survival training in a variety of climatic conditions, the
circumstances described by Mr. MONTAGNA
do not accurately represent reality. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s claim of
being presented a 48 star flag by President Johnson, on
the White House lawn, for "Duty to his Country" is patently
absurd! At the time that President Johnson served in office there were
FIFTY (50) states in the union... and there had been since 1959; no
reason could justify or explain presentation of a 48 star flag when
there were 50 states in the union. Mr. MONTAGNA’s
claims of being unable to travel due to his claimed SEAL service are
without merit. Real US Navy SEALs travel as civilians after they leave
the service without difficulties. His claim of someone “having his
name and still looking for him” is ludicrous and unrealistic; such
claims are the stuff of Hollywood and nothing more. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s
claims of service in Vietnam are not supported by government
documentation (DD-214). US Navy SEALs who served in the Vietnam War, no
matter how secretive or covert their activities, all show Vietnam
service on their DD-214 Report of Separation documents. Again, his
claims are taken straight from the movie screen and bear no resemblance
to the reality of military service. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s use of
the phrase “rang his own bell” is a complete fabrication based upon
media descriptions of the manner in which SEAL Trainees may voluntarily
end their participation in TRAINING. Once a man gets to the SEAL Teams
he is obligated for a specific number of years of service with the Teams
before he may “UN-volunteer”. The only way this legal contract may
be terminated early is by death or injury, and the decision regarding
whether a man is capable of continuing duty as a SEAL is left to medical
professionals. There is no “bell ringing” once training is
completed. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s claims of
being taught how to kill “swift and silent” are without merit since
it is well known to the public at large that training of this nature is
the standard for all Special Operations Forces in the US military. His
further claim of being trained to “make someone pay” is nothing more
than a pitiful attempt at intimidating his listeners against questioning
his claims. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s wearing of a
US Naval Officer’s uniform, no matter what color the pips on his
shoulder, is a breach of Title 18 of the US Code, Section 702, as it
pertains to the unlawful wearing of a uniform of the US armed forces for
which the wearer has no formal authorization… either an actual uniform
or facsimile thereof. This is a prosecutable offense and if convicted,
he may be subject to fines, imprisonment, or both. This violation of
FEDERAL LAW should be reported to federal law enforcement agents (I
recommend the FBI) along with any photographic evidence you might have
which clearly depicts Mr. MONTAGNA
in such attire. Given
the preposterous nature of all the claims offered by Mr. MONTAGNA
I am absolutely certain that his claims of being a SEAL Sniper are
entirely without merit. This may be ascertained by asking him to
identify his Sniper training class number, graduation date, and training
location. This information can then be compared to official DoD
documentation for verification or denial. Mr.
MONTAGNA’s wearing of
the US Navy SEAL “Trident” patch is a direct violation of the same
Title 18, USC, Section 702, as it pertains to the unlawful wearing of
any military unit insignia, badges, patches, pins, tabs,
awards, commendations, medals, or uniform garments (or facsimile
thereof) for which one did not have formal/official authorization. Such
actions are listed as a prosecutable offense under Title 18 US Code
Section 702 which specifies up to $5,000 in fines and up to 6 months
imprisonment per each count on which an offender was convicted. This
section of the USC has been recently amended and signed into law (20 Dec
2006) making it a punishable offense to offer false VERBAL
claims of receiving “any of the
service medals or badges awarded to the members of such forces, the
ribbon, button, or rosette of any such badge, decoration, or medal, or
any colorable imitation of such item”. As Mr. MONTAGNA’s
has apparently gone beyond the offering of simple verbal claims and
undertaken the actual wearing of the SEAL Team emblem, he is clearly in
violation of Title 18 USC and chargeable under the both the spirit and
the word of that law. I
would strongly encourage you to disseminate the foregoing information to
anyone who might have been the victim of Mr. MONTAGNA’s
fantasies, braggadocio, chest-thumping bravado, and outright falsehoods.
I might suggest that your local print and broadcast media be contacted
in this regard; if I can be of any further assistance to either you or
them in exposing Mr. MONTAGNA’s
charade and preventing him from misleading others, please feel free to
contact me. Thank you
again for your concern in this matter, and for your assistance in
upholding the honor of the US Navy SEAL Teams. As noted in my opening
paragraph, I am a private individual and am in no way affiliated with
the US Department of Defense or the US government. Despite any reports
you may make/send to me regarding Mr. MONTAGNA’s
false SEAL claims, any such information which I might pass along to the
authorities in this matter would be classified as “hearsay” and
therefore inadmissible in a court of law. The responsibility for
reporting the individual named in your inquiry to the federal
authorities rests with you and with anyone else who may have personally
heard or received these claims from the individual himself. Whether or
not you decide to report him to the federal authorities is entirely up
to you, but at least you now know the truth regarding his bogus claims.
If I can be of any further assistance to you in this matter, please
contact me at your convenience. Very respectfully Steve
Robinson |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Montgomery,
James Alwyn
aka
Dr. or Prof. Montgomery |
2005 | Australia
Florida |
James
Montgomery: Exposed in Australia
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Lovefraud.com launched with the story of how James Montgomery
defrauded Donna Andersen. At the same time, the Coalition of Patriots
for Military Honor, an Australian organization that exposes military
imposters, debunked Montgomery's service claims on its website.
Montgomery was soon featured in a Sydney newspaper under the headline "Meet Major Fraud." Montgomery admitted that he fabricated military documents, but claimed it was part of a "secret government project to demonstrate how easy it is to impersonate a war hero." Due to his fraudulent past, Montgomery lost his university job. Read on True Lovefraud Stories - James Montgomery ========================================= On Feb 10, 2006, James A, Montgomery, SFA member A-939 was found to be in such serious violation of the SFA constitution that it required immediate expulsion. The proceedings were initiated, Montgomery was given an opportunity to either appear at a formal hearing or voluntarily resign without further recourse. On Feb 1, he signed a voluntary resignation. He has been expelled from SFA Chapter LX and his name struck from the roster. National has done the same and it will be formally announced in the Spring edition of The Drop. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Mooney, Robert | . | Virginia | Claims Medal of Honor. DECEASED - had MOH license plate for 5 yrs. | . | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Moore, Edward Dean | 09/2006 | KY | SEE CLAIMS AND RECORDS | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||