Back to Index

Heroes or Villains?

INTRODUCTION

CLAIMING VIETNAM PRISONER OF WAR:

V V A - Claims by members of  Vietnam Veterans of America

==================================
Reported Claims of:
Medal of Honor, Other than Vietnam POWs, Son Tay Raiders, DSC, DFC, Purple Heart, Silver Star, Bronze Star, Navy Cross, SEALS, Rangers, Pilots, Special Forces, Green Berets, Combat, Vietnam Helicopter Pilots, Flying Tigers, DOUBT EVERYTHING, Don't Encourage and more.

APOLOGIES AND CLARIFICATIONS

Individuals reported as of 02/2012
CLAIMS AS NOTED 
#  =  on list over 15 years

All claims highlighted in lavender may be eligible for prosecution under U.S. Code Title 18  or under the  STOLEN VALOR ACT signed into law Dec 20, 2006.

Note: The names listed in the next pages have made VARIOUS or multiple claims
that cannot be substantiated or have been proven FALSE. 

These individuals
are IN ADDITION TO those investigated and named in the book STOLEN VALOR.

Those with a "LINK" have records, news articles, pictures or tales posted.
All names are first checked here  http://www.dtic.mil/dpmo/ if POW claims are made. 

Comments in GREEN are from information contained in military records (or lack of military records) obtained
through FOIA when requested THROUGH the National Personnel Records Center in St. Louis.

THOSE CLAIMING MEDAL OF HONOR
NOTE: In 1996 HLI Lordship Industries (at the time, the OFFICIAL USG contractor for the Medal of Honor) admitted selling THREE HUNDRED unauthorized medals for $75.00 each from 1991-1994. They were fined $80,000. NOT ALL of those medals have been recovered. Offenders in possession of an unauthorized medal can be arrested, fined ( The maximum fine for a criminal offense is $250,000, pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 3571(b)(3) ) and jailed (up to a year). It is the only military medal that CANNOT be bought, sold, bartered, traded, collected, auctioned, exchanged.... EVERY Medal of Honor is awarded by act of Congress. Less than 84 REAL Medal of Honor recipients are alive today.
 

C  [1]

Name Location Date reported ALL Claim POW or MIA and then some

Actual Records Indicate/Notes

Caffaro, John
aka Goslin, John Samuel
New Jersey 04/1998
10/99
In phone conversation claimed 1st MAW in Phu Bai, Cambodia ops. 
Has "all the paperwork" to support his POW claims.
Records indicate served from 09/29/67 to 12/06/68, PFC... served RVN 27 My 1968 "AdminMan" till 10 Sept 68 "sick".. NO Purple Heart. Awards and decorations: national Defense, Vietnam Service Medal.

CALLAHAN, WILLIAM F 

AKA BILL CALLAHAN

TX 03/2010 Claims SF, Prisoner of War. . 
Calvo, David R. "Dupont"
aka "Dupont", David R.Calvo
Fort Walton Beach. FL 11/2000
multiple reports
Claims POW, Warrant officer, helicopter pilot Has VA POW ID CARD
Camp, Dan Charles Allen County, IN 06/2005 Claims he graduated at age 17 and had to get his parents permission to enlist in the Navy.  Originally wanted to be a helicopter mechanic - was a door gunner on a helicopter and served one tour.  He did not say he was a SEAL but that he was somehow recruited while in country to join them on one or more missions.  He said they had sought one or more volunteers to go with them into Laos.  His activities there were classified.  

He said his first wife divorced him after he was shot down in Cambodia and listed as missing.  He claimed to have been held underground in a 4x4x4' box until some of his comrades went against orders and returned to rescue  him.

 

 

Daniel Charles Camp is not now and never was a US Navy SEAL, and was NEVER solicited by a SEAL unit to accompany them on combat operations. The SEAL Teams never (NEVER) call for volunteers to accompany them on combat operations! The members of a SEAL platoon train intensely together as a small unit for many months (sometimes close to one full year) before deploying anywhere in order that they might effectively work together as a cohesive unit. Their reactions to situations and circumstances become so integrated that their interactions and coordinated movements in combat seem to take on the aspect of telepathy. No words are necessary between the SEALs because they all know their jobs, their responsibilities, and what other platoon members expect of them. To introduce an untrained outsiderinto that closely knit and tightly coordinated unit is a truly insane concept. 

Born in 1947. Served from Jul 1 66 to June 21 1972. Navy AMS3. ONLY medal, National Defense. Court Martial transcript "not in file." Attened "P", "A" school and corrosion control training. NO RECORD OR ANY COMBAT OR OVERSEAS DUTY.

Works for Police Dept.

Campbell, A.E. . . Claims POW .
Campbell, Michael Craig Burley ID 01/2006 the tale, the records, the comments ...... .
CAMPBELL, BOYCE JOHN

AKA LEROY MORALES

AKA EARL RAY CALLIHAN

MS 04/2010 Claims POW -  there in 1959 and that his helicopter was shot down.  He claims a "Russian" cut off his finger while he was in captivity. 

                 
.
Campbell, Terri . . Claims POW .
Campbell. Thomas E. . 2005 Claims while on a classified mission "SFC" Campbell was captured.  After being captured, Campbell managed to escape and rescue a Navy Pilot that was also imprisoned.  Claims to have been awarded a Navy Cross for the incident, yet no documentation exists. Letter re: POW info
Campofiore, Joseph Alexander Virginia 05/2005 Claims he served in the 173rd airborne  "magnificent bastards" in Vietnam during the late 60's early 70's.  He told me he was staff sergeant and was awarded a Purple Heart  and a cross and was taken prisoner for 3 days by the viet cong. ... was forced to watch 2 of his "boys" be slowly tortured to death by the viet cong. He told me that after about 3 days he was rescued by the Americans. He said that he has no veteran benefits because he was arrested for murder after Vietnam and the government stripped him of all his benefits and medals.  .... .
CANTU,  AL

aka ALBRTO OROSCO  CANTU

TX 05/2011

http://www.kztv10.com/news/local-war-hero-recounts-days-as-pow/
 
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/43218908

Local War Hero Recounts Days as POW
Posted: May 30, 2011 4:21 PM by Melissa Schroeder - mschroeder@kristv.com
Updated: May 30, 2011 6:58 PM

......Al Cantu served in the Army during the Vietnam War.

His chopper got shot down in 1969.

He and the other survivors were taken prisoner.

Cantu said, "I was thinking I was not going to make it. Everyday I said I'm going to die, I'm going to die, but I kept praying."

Cantu endured 89 days of torture by the enemy. ......

NOT A POW

 

Actual records

 

 

CANTU, "GUY" EDUARDO

COMMAND SGT MAJOR

SCHERTZ, TX 04/2010 His story is that he was on the ground in N. Vietnam on a highly classified mission. He inferred that he was a spy (his field was intelligence) at a time when we were not flying missions over the North. He said his function was to assist in SAR efforts. ( if we weren't flying missions over the North then, why did we need a SAR effort?)

My friend said Cantu shared his story of incarceration once on the golf course as they talked of their combat experiences. He said they "found him out" on one occasion...the reason he felt like he had failed his mission, and that he was put in a bamboo pen for a period of 57 days.  An arc light hit very close (again he said he was captured when we weren't flying over the North!), the gomers ran for cover and only one guy was left guarding him.  That guard backed up against the pen and Guy reached through the bars and took him out.  He escaped and disappeared into the jungle. 

Guy has not asked to be a member of repatriated POWs.
I asked him why not and he said because he never surrendered. 
Obviously he was alone and only he knows fact from fiction.  The fact that his actions were totally covert guarantees that there will be no record of any incarceration and/or escapes.  There are no records. 

Could you please check your database and see if you have  Command Sergeant Major Guy Cantu, Ret Army E-9.   He's not on the PMSEA.  Service Jan 67 - 31 Mar 71.

72 YRS OLD IN 2010

-----------------------------------------------------------------

While attending the Freedom flyers reunion at Randolph AFB, I met a retired Army Sgt who claimed to have been a POW in Laos for a short period.  He attended our dining-in.  I questioned him but he was evasive. Special Forces, secret missions etc.  It all sounds familiar to you , I know.  Anyway, I do not have any info on him yet except his name and rank and that he lives in the San Antonio area.  He did say he retired in 1987 or 1988 from the Army. 

================================

The man is Command Sergeant Major Eduardo "Guy" Cantu and that he served 30 years in the USA before retiring in 1989...   He claims to have been held 59 days but there is no record because he was not in uniform and was doing Special Forces work.
From: "Mike McGrath" <mmcgrath62@comcast.net>
To: "P.O.W. Network - Chuck and Mary Schantag" <info@pownetwork.org>
Date: Mon, 26 Apr 2010 12:26:19 -0600
Subject: CANTU

 
Tell Cantu that Cordier is a gentleman...not suited to fighting.  However, I would be glad to meet Cantu in the gym for an introduction.  Tell him I am on the wall in Stillwater, OK in the Wrestling Hall of Fame.  Also, please relay my sentiments that Cantu is a fraud, a "wannabe."  Department of  Defense has no knowledge of his fraudulent claim.  His service record likewise would fail to show any substantiation.  His medical record.  No After Action Report, no casualty reports, no missing personnel reports, no morning muster reports, no official notification to Next of Kin, no assignment of a CACO to assist the family, no Western Union telegram, no nothin' to support a silly and unsubstantiated claim.  All 3,797 officially listed and known MIAs (to include all POWs, all CIA and other secret operatives, civilians, secret missions, etc.) all are listed at the following official site:
   
Mr. Cantu is not listed.  He is a wannbe.

 
Mike McGrath
Historian, NAM-POWs
~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Date: Mon, 26 Apr 2010 21:59:42 -0600
Subject: Cantu.  He's a wannabe. 
Reply-to: mmcgrath62@comcast.net

 

Yep...he's a wannbe.  Probably has a self esteem problem, like most of the 2,000 plus wannabes we see. 
 
...it is impossible for a guy to be missing from his unit for that length of
time without a lot of fuss.  What about after action reports, morning muster reports, casualty reports, required reports to the family within 24 hours, Western Union telegram, official notification to the family from the nearest base commander and chaplain, news articles, assignment of a CACO to assist the family, service record entries, medical records entries, and on and on.  Awards, decorations, citations, etc.  None produced so far.  The guy is a loser.  I offered to meet him in the gym this morning (as Ken's second). 
 
He has the typical BS story that all 2,000 phony POWs think will pass
muster.   It was a secret mission.  It is still classified.  I killed a guard and made a miraculous escape through hundreds of miles of enemy territory.   My CO never reported it.  My service record was burned in the St. Louis fire.
 
The Department of Defense has  never heard of the guy in this regard. 
Their offical web site listing all 3,797 MIAs (to include all POWs, CIA,
clandestine ops, civilians, etc.) is at the following site; 
   
If Mr. Cantu can prove the PMSEA wrong, he will be the first of over 2,000 wannabes in the past 35 years to do so.  Sort of long odds. 
 
The guy's a loser.  Dump him. 
 
Mike McGrath
NAM-POW Historian
~~~~~~~~~~~~
CANYON, BRICE Lake Texoma Texas 12/2008 Claims he was  in the US Air Force. That he was a pilot during the Vietnam war and was shot down. Upon crash landing his aircraft, he injured his eye and his face was covered with blood so he gave his weapon to his co-pilot. He claimed that his co-pilot was killed and he was captured and held as a POW.

He stated that he was a POW for 9 months until his POW camp was bombed by US Forces and he was able to escape.

Claims he is 59 years old, but  on a dating site called, "Plenty of Fish," his name, Brice Canyon, is his user name and he is listed as being 53 years old. He has pictures of himself posted on that site.

 

THE NAME MAY BE FALSE - NO TRACE IN THE COUNTRY FOR ANYONE NAMED BRICE CANYON.

 

 

Capach, Charles L.E.

aka Charles LeCapach

. 08/2004 hi my name is chief charles.l.e.capach i was 22years in us army i went to range school in 1963 i was all so specialforces i went to jungle school and pathfinder school and diver school  i was with sog and bluelight light or sfod-d work with rvn rangers fpr 2years i am a member of the flowins assos heare sf,assoc mike force and war ranger life member 565 u.s.mra life member special ops assoc i was in nam for 7years was a p.o.w and was in laso for a time i was a SP/7 E-7 then became a cwo-4 in georgia then became a O-5 ltc in g.a. guard i
am now working as a indian marshal in n,y and g,a. and n.c i am now
going  blind becouse of suger and combat woundshope you can all read
this note to you all i was also a teacher at ranger school i was with
the 5th ranger bn mountany traning school and was teacher at M.A.C.V.
RECONDO SCHOOL TO FOR A TIME AS ALWAYS KEEP UP TYE GOOD WORK AND
rangers lead the way   yours truley chief or ltc OLD RANGERS NEVER
DIE THE JUST LEAD THE WAY MUCH SLOWER BUT BETTER SOME
WAYS                  
SFOD1732@YAHOO.COM                                                   
                                PPS.I FOR GOT IWAS WITH THE 173
2BN .CO.N AND WITH THE173 2BN A.CO



I never sad i was a pow in nam you know there was
other places like laso cambo and cuba do you know
about A-66 AND CUBA? HOW ABOUT WHITESTAR LASO? AND HOW
ABOUT mavsog?NO NAMES NO DOGTAGS NO ONE TO BACK YOU UP
I JUST LIE TO SAY THIS LOOK IN YOUR BOOKS AND SE IF
TELLS YOU ABOUT THILAND AND SPECIAL FORCES RANGERS IN
THILAND 46SFCO AND LOOK IN YOUR BOOKS ABOUT LZ
ENGLISH?

===========================================================

SF Mike Force Assn Honcho regarding his MSF claims:
No Christmas turkey has ever been so full of shit.
.
Capp, Richard Francis England 01/2011 Richard Francis Capp ( ex-green bay Packer and Steelers football player) claims  that he was in  a U2 plane which was shot down and he ejected safely, but fell into enemy hands and was chained to a post for 2 years.  He said he received the Silver Star personally from President Kennedy.  Apparently, he was a helicopter pilot that flew the one of the helicopters into Saigon for the U.S. Embassy evacuation ( fall of Saigon). He also claimed it was the North Vietnamese that help him captive for 2 years.

 

ACTUAL RECORDS

Mary & Doug,

I'm gonna go out on a limb here and call this one a complete fraud.  I just happen to have a list of EVERY person who has ever flown in the U-2, and there is nobody with that name on the list.  Also, they didn't award Silver Stars for being a POW or taking torture before the Vietnam War...generally, the highest award given was the Legion of Merit (and sometimes the Distinguished Service Medal) pre-Vietnam (again, Olmstead and McKone were awarded their Silver Stars years later).

Happy New Year,

-Erich

Erich Anderson
Veteran Tributes Founder
P.O. Box 3012
Gulfport, MS 39505
(228) 861-8985
www.veterantributes.org

-----------------------------------
 
Mary,
I just finished going through the Cold War DPMO files in the last couple weeks. With Erich‚s great help, we found two men who were shot down in 1960 on an aircraft with a crew of six. These two men (John McKone and Freeman Olmstead) were held as POWs by the Soviets for six months and were subsequently awarded Silver Stars. This case, which would have gone pretty much unknown except for Erich‚s great work, inclines me to think there are possibly others. But the thing that makes me doubt this case is:
1) Both these men are listed by DPMO,
2) Both these men did NOT receive their Silver Stars until decades later (as opposed to this guy who claims it was presented by JFK).
 
Perhaps Erich can shed some light on this.
 
Sincerely,

Doug
Capps, Thomas E. . 12/2002 Claims POW ESCAPEE. USMC Nam May 66 - Mar 67 .
Carl, William Von . . Claims POW .
Carpenter, Bert . 09/2005 http://www.ocala.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050922/NEWS07/209220385/1011

Bertrand Carpenter, 71
CITRUS SPRINGS - Bertrand " Bert" Carpenter, 71, a retired nuclear instructor, died Sunday, Sept. 18, 2005.

A native of Philadelphia, he moved here from Williamstown, N.J., in 1995. Mr. Carpenter was a U.S. Navy veteran of the Korean and Vietnam wars. He was a prisoner of war during the Vietnam War and was awarded the Purple Heart. He was a member of the Veterans of Foreign Wars Post 4864 and of Grace Baptist Church.

....  Hopper Funeral Homes, Beverly Hills Chapel, provided information.

.
Carr, James E Tustin, CA 01/2006
Claims he was shot down in a huey and taken prisoner for about two months. When pressed about details "he didn't want to talk about it, it brings up to many bad memories"
Claims "he was in the back."  He even goes as far as telling his associates that he was a "hero" and fought for their freedom! He took his photo with Bob Dornan the founder of the POW bracelet (trying to add truth to his story). Uses this story to run his realty business

Working as a realtor in Tustin CA. His website is http://www3.helpusell.com/CarrRealty/Listings/Residential.aspx

.
CARR,  RICHARD L Forsyth, MO
Carrollton, IL
04/2008 Claims escaped from the Hanoi Hilton NEVER A POW

actual records

Carrio, Miquel
aka Mike
Houston, TX . POW, Green Beret, Air America convicted felon
Carroll, Willie  Arthur FL 03/2006

05/2006

11/2008
Claims POW from Vietnam, USMC, Special Forces. Claims 8 yrs service - 1962 - 1970. Claims Capt or Major. Claims Purple Heart.  Claims hands registered as "deadly weapons." Speaks at USMC recruiting station, local high school. Claims he works with/for Homeland Security. Drives an 18 wheeler. Claims daily nightmares from captivity. He has been showing off a Purple Heart and claiming it was from Vietnam. 

St. Louis could locate NO MILITARY RECORDS of any kind. THEY want to see proof he served!
Carter, Chuck

claims lives in tent in Louisville, MS; from IL, heading for Dothan, AL

01/2001 POW, 82nd Airborne, captured 1970 held 1.5 yrs!   .
Carter,  Keith Creton  Arizona, 
Englewood - Golden Colorado
02/2004

12/2009

Claims Green Beret in Vietnam, a POW for 186 days in a remote camp that no one knew about.  Claims he escaped after 186 days of torture, having no body hair, burned feet, front teeth cut completely out from a knife.  As they took him outside of the camp blindfolded and on his knees, they put a gun to his head and pulled the trigger, which misfired and killed the shooter allowing him to escape. He did three tours and was severely wounded, spending time on the ship REPOSE and then over a year at Walter Reed Hospital.  He said he had the DSC awarded to him November 3, 1973 and Nixon pinned it on his uniform on the White House lawn the middle of December 1973.  He belonged to Company B.  His missions were always secretive.  He also was awarded the bronze star (which he refused), two silver stars, five purple hearts, Viet Nam service medal ..... 
Drives a 1993 Plymouth Colt now that his Century was "stolen". Same Purple Heart plate may be on the Colt.
 

2009- Claims POW in Vietnam, a Green Beret, who earned 2 Silver Stars, Purple Hearts and a host of other medals, and was nominated for the CMOH by Senator Strom Thurmond. 

 
Has stories of his captivity, the secret missions he went on, and his war wounds.  Claims that he's been homeless, could not hold down a job, and was given the runaround by the VA concerning his medical care and benefits.  
NO RECORDS FOUND
Case, Dennis MI again 06/2006 Claims POW

Case, Raymond . 10/2001
02/2002
Claims USMC Sgt Maj, Silver Star, Bonze Star, Navy Cross, Operation Oregon, 1st Force Recon or claims POW and the above - 4th Marine Recon. .
Cashin, Joe . . Claims POW .
CASSAVETES, FRANK

aka DIMUNGO, RONALD FRANK

CA 03/2008

quote

Frank Cassavetes is not only an actor and personal trainer to some of Hollywood's superstars, but he is also a hero. A marine veteran of 27 years, with 29 months in combat in Viet Nam. Captured, he became a prisoner of war for five years, the last three at the infamous Hanoi Hilton prisoner of war camp. For the last ten years of his military career, Frank was a drill instructor at the Marine training camp at Paris Island.

Most will recognize Frank as the sniper in the movie "John Q" with Denzel Washington, who Frank also worked with as a personal trainer. At the time of this writing, Frank was getting ready for roles in movies with Michael Caine, Robert Duval, and his brother, the well known producer Nick Cassavetes.

end quote

NOT A POW. 

ACTUAL RECORDS

CASSIDY, DAVID
aka  DAVE CASSIDY
DE, PA 01/2009 Claims USMC, Prisoner of War for 4.5 months. Escaped with TEN other POWs. Is a locksmith. Drives a black truck. May work with LOCKMOBILE. CLAIMS to be a member of American Ex-POWs. 
National states "NOT."

ACTUAL RECORDS

CASTEEL,  BOYD TN 04/2008 Well first thing, I guess is my name. My name is Boyd Casteel. I am 54 years old and I am married to a wonderful wife, Lisa. We are big animal lovers so we have quite a few pets. We live in Northeast Tennessee, in Johnson City , TN.

I am a retired police officer. Law Enforcement has been a part of my life since I was 18 years old. I am an Air Force veteren, learning my police duties there and then going in to civilian law enforcement, once I left the Air Force.

I am a former POW. My unit was ambushed in Viet Nam , myself and one other person were the only two survivors that day. We were quickly taken to a POW camp, interrogated and tortured, then placed in 4' by 4' bamboo cages the were outside the commanding officer offices and left there for the duration of my stay.According to the Geneva Convention, POS's are allowed Red Cross packages and medical attention......my buddy and I were not. We were fed a small amount of stale bread and very very small pieces of some kind of meat, mostly fat along with some water,once a day.We were tortured relentlessly, every day. In those days, all we were only allowed to say if captured, was name, rank, and serial number. Believe me friends, after a few days of beatings, you can't give them any info....you really don't even know your own name anymore. I actually prayed for death but it never came.

I was kept confined for 9 months, when the camp was taken by several Marine outfits. The Red Cross came in and tended to all of the wounded and all the GI's that were considered critical care.

I was transported to a hospital ship to start my rehabilitation to where I could stand and walk again, then after a few months I was sent back to the States ( Anchorage , AK ) to complete my service.

As horrible as that all sounds, it is just now, that I am able to really start talking about. It has stayed with me most all of my adult life. Some of it never goes away.

==================================

Thank you for the link to the POW/MIA website. Over the years, I have researched through many archives, wrote tons of letters, even made phone calls only to find out that there are many vets who have wrong info or info that was never updated in their military files. Some have spent a lot of their civilian career and most of their savings trying to correct their files and write history the way it was meant to be written, especially for their families.

Most folks do not understand what one piece of a servicemans file, misplaced, can do. To some it can be completely devastating. It can mean the difference between medical help, and just getting by in the remaining years of ones llife.

Please don't think me a hero, for I am NOT. I was just a young kid who had some unforunate events take place in his life. The real hero's, well, sadly some of them are still there. Gratefully, some are in Arlington , but one thing is for sure....they are all with the Great Commander, Our Lord and Savior. Most, maybe not all are listed on The Wall in Washington . But you know probably as well as I do, that to lose 58,000 of our countries greatest heros's was not and never will acceptable.

Please forgive my "soapbox" mentality. Sometimes a nerve gets struck, and I just can't help myself. Most of the country didn't want to hear about Viet Nam then, and a lot still don't want to hear about it, now. But, I for one will never stop talking about the atrocities that happen to both sides, ours and theirs.

I don't usually speak about the war. It's over and I try to put the heartache and misery behind me, but some of the guys we fly with wanted to know about me, so I let my guard down and opened up a little bit. Not for any type of adulation or pats on the back, but maybe to just let all know that some of us are still out here, and what it was like back in the 60's and 70's.

Thank you for your letter, and most of all thank you, Ken, for YOUR service. It is young men and women like you that still make this the best country in the world. As bad as it was, I would still reenlist today and do it all over again, if youth and time were on my side.

God bless you and all like you who protect us each day, and most of all, God bless America .


I remain,

your friend,

Boyd

Boyd Casteel, DVMO1144
General
Vice President
Delta Virtual Military Operations

This case is still under investigation. There is a possibility even the "biographical data" other than the names are bogus in this fairy tale. 

There is no historical evidence to back up the claims.

Caufman, Dave NC 11/2002 Claims POW 18 MONTHS, ESCAPED with 2 Marines and 1 Air Force Pilot, Claims Seabee, captured near Quang Tri Works for termite control company.
Cavanagh, Wm. J. Jr NJ . Claims POW records indicate NO captivity
Castor, Ken Boulder, CO
previously from 
Kansas City, KS.
. POW and CIA convicted for fraud -  NO military service
Cayton, Command SgtMaj (Ret) Rick

aka Richard B. Cayton

aka Richard Barr Cayton

aka Rick Cayton

Killeen, TX

Harker Heights, TX

Belton, TX
working in Houston

Has address in GA - but living in RV in TX after selling the boat shop.

12/2002
02/2004
03/2005

2006 (repeated reports)

2007

2008

11/2011

 

April 11, 2009

AP: More POW claimants than actual POWs   

----------------------------------------------------------

Quoted in Killeen Daily Herald 02/24/2002 "Survivor Types: Residents overcome odds, become better human beings" 

...That same someone needs me intensity compelled POW Cayton to persevere in January 1971. The Viet Cong attacked Sgt. Caytons six man squad at night in a quick, fierce fight......
                                          ==============

MORE AND MORE - JUST CLICK HERE

Cayton claims: 
Distinguished Service Medal
2 Silver Stars
3 Legion of Merit
4 Bronze Stars
2 Bronze Stars w/V
5 Purple Hearts
3 Meritorious Service
3 Air Medals
3 Joint Service Commendations
Army Commendation Medal
Joint Service Achievement Medal
8 Army Good Conduct
2 National Defense Medal
Armed Forces Expeditionary Medal w/bronze Arrowhead
4 Vietnam Service Medals
Southwest Asia Service Medal w/3 Bronze Service Stars
Humanitarian Service Medal
4 NCO Professional Development Ribbons
Army Service Ribbon
3 Overseas Service Ribbon
Republic of Vietnam Campaign Medal
Kuwait Liberation Medal
Joint Meritorious Unit Award
Valorous Unit Award
Combat Infantryman Badge
Master Parachute Badge w/Bronze Service Star
Aircraft Crewman Badge
Canadian Parachute Badge
Republic of Vietnam Gallantry Cross Unit Citation with Palm
Ranger Tab
Rifle M16 expert qualification badge
Pistol 9MM expert qualification badge
.45 cal expert qualification badge

THIS ONE'S NOT OVER YET.

December 2007 - http://www.kdhnews.com/news/story.aspx?id=21064

UPDATE

St. Louis has been unable to provide orders or dates of issue on many of the medals noted in his records - and the list differs from the records noted on his DD214.

Command Sgt Major Cayton's  DD214 states "POW"

Command Sgt Major Cayton's  records claims "POW"

==========================================

Steve. There's more to the story....

Today there were a whole bunch of replies to my quarry. It seems that this guy was held in serious contempt by junior members of the battalion, several of whom went on to get commissioned and at least one of whom is still on active duty. According to these guys, he was the consummate self promoter, egomaniac and all around asshole. This is not just from some private who thought the guy was a hardass - quite the contrary. All the guys that replied either retired from active duty or at least reached NCO rank before ETS'ing. It says something when not a single guy had anything positive to say.

Clayton evidently told the POW story complete with torture, etc. to each RIP class he taught. For a time he was assigned to the 1/75 Ranger Indoc Program at Hunter before the Regt was activated and that function consolidated at Ft. Benning.

There's a good chance this POW stuff is all hot air on his part - simply based on the rabid responses I got. 

Hope this helps. It's simply more of the total picture of this guy. Bob

==========================

Richard Cayton | Facebook
Richard Cayton is on Facebook. Join Facebook to connect with Richard Cayton 

and others you may know. Facebook gives people the power to share and makes the ..

   


 
At 06:44 PM 11/1/2011,wrote:
Not sure if you are still tracking this guy but I will update you. Retired CSM Richard Barr Cayton is currently working in Iraq as a security contractor on a DoS contract with a company by the name of Triple Canopy. He has obviously continued his deceptive and self promoting behavior by failing to declare his past lies. He currently holds a DoS Secret security clearance which is required, so has obviously failed to disclose that he falsified his military records which led to a CID investigation. I'm sure this would have led to a denial of his clearance. Why DoS investigators failed to do a simple Google search on this guy is beyond me.
 

Rick Cayton - Soldier, Hero, American
This link/content has been removed from the web. This link goes to a SAVED page copy now.

GOOGLE search:

Richard B. Cayton. This website is the only authorized and accurate website with information about me and my career in the United States Army. ...
ultimatelocksales.com/rickcayton/ - 6k - Cached - Similar pages
CECIL, CHARLES RAYMOND LOUISVILLE, KY 05/2010

01/2012

  ALTERED DD214 IS NOT AN OFFICIAL DOC
 
Claims he held POW in either Laos or Cambodia for a year. He escaped and returned to his "buddies".  He is frequently driven to the VA for services.

 

NOT A POW.
Chamberlain, William Lee  III . . Claims POW .
Chambers, William E.
aka Col Wild Bill Chambers
CA # Claimed Col, Medal of Honor, POW, in cell with Alvarez, hung upside down 31 days, Homecoming flight in 1973 by helicopter. Claims 782,000 dollars in back pay. Exposed by Carole Thompson, June 9, 1989 in the Antelope Valley Press. 
Dob Dec 27
CHAMPE,  GARY S

DECEASED

IN 09/2008
Gary S. Champe, 59, of Dillsboro passed away Tuesday, September 2, 2008 at the University Hospital in Cincinnati. He was born at Knoxville, Tennessee on March 12, 1949 the son of Allen and Doris Case Champe. He was married to Beverly Chipman on May 17, 2003 and she survives. Other survivors include his mother Doris Champe of Dillsboro. Mr. Champe was US Army Retired having served 25 years in the military. He was a former POW and had served three tours of duty in Vietnam. He received three Commendation Medals, two Achievement Medals, and the Good Conduct Medal. ...

http://74.125.95.104/search?q=cache:lch6F4C7nQgJ:www.seidata.com/~ripleynews/vrobituaries.html+Gary+S.+Champe&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=1&gl=us

NOT A POW

ACTUAL RECORDS

Chance, Gilbert  Alabama . POW 13 Months, MOH "Home, brew and Jesus helped  Vietnam POW escape" -
records in hand EXPOSED
Chapman, Thomas Henry III .   Claims POW .
CHARBONNET, FELDER JOSEPH New Orleans 03/2011 He is an actor that claims he was a pirate killer with Team 6 and a SEAL from 90-96.  He tells film people here this so he can get jobs on film sets as a consultant to make sure they do special op scenes correctly.  Tried over and over to get his class number during BUDS and he avoided the question.
Here's a link to his Facebook page: 
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001650342106


 
I called this Felder Charbonnet guy and asked if he was a Navy SEAL, he replied "Yes." Noteworthy is that he claims BUD/S Class 287, SEAL Team SIX, and a SEAL from 90-96. The noteworthy part is that BUD/S Class 287 began Hell Week two days ago on March 6th, 2011... Felder is a crappy little actor dude in New Orleans (like New Orleans hasn't had enough problems already) who uses his SEAL claims to get acting jobs and as a consultant for Special Ops films and shows.
He removed one resume post where he stated he was a Navy Boatswain Mate "BM" and qualified as Helm and Lee Helmsman...
 
Its no wonder there are so many crappy movies about the Military with guys like this Clown giving advice on Special Operations...
 Don

Felder Nola'Actor     

Actual Records:


 

Sir,

I greatly appreciate your interest in upholding the honor of the US Navy SEAL Teams, and your search for the TRUTH. Before answering your questions I must make clear that I am a private individual, not affiliated with the US Dept. of Defense or any other government organization. My efforts to expose SEAL imposters are performed as a service to the public, and in honor of my fallen SEAL Teammates… men who truly earned the right to the title “US NAVY SEAL” but who are no longer able to stand forward in defense of their honor, their reputations, and their TEAMs.

If the name you provided is spelled correctly, I do NOT find a listing in the SEAL Database (SEAL Teams and predecessor units from 1943 to the Present Day) for anyone named FELDER CHARBONNET. I have also examined possible alternate spellings, and names with similar pronunciations without finding any that appear to be applicable.

Unless he has undertaken the unlikely action of a legal name change (an action for which there would be evidence in the form of court documentation) since his claimed participation in SEAL training, and based upon the information you have provided, I can state conclusively that FELDER CHARBONNET has NEVER COMPLETED SEAL training, and he is not now, nor was he ever a Navy SEAL, a Navy UDT “Frogman”, a member of any Naval Combat Demolition Unit (NCDU), or a member of the Naval Amphibious Scouts & Raiders (S&R).

Many SEAL imposters when confronted with the information I have provided will resort to claiming that their records are sealed, burned or their SEAL Operations were Classified and that there are no official records of them.

Before any classified operations may be undertaken as a SEAL Operator, a man must first successfully complete the Basic Underwater Demolition/SEAL (BUD/S) Training program and then the follow-on secondary training program. The names of all those who successfully graduate from that training program sequence are compiled in the SEAL database. Later participation in classified operations has "no impact" on whether or not a person is listed as a graduate of the training program.

There are records of every man who has qualified for the title of “SEAL”; there have been and will continue to be secret missions, but there are NO secret SEALs.

Once again I must stress that although I am a US Navy veteran, and a former SEAL, I am a civilian performing in an entirely unofficial role. I strongly recommend that you obtain a formal/official US NAVY statement regarding Mr. FELDER CHARBONNET claimed SEAL credentials. To do so you may contact the FOIA COORDINATOR at the NAVAL SPECIAL WARFARE COMMAND in San Diego, California, and submit a formal FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT inquiry in writing addressed to:

Commander
Naval Special Warfare Command
FOIA Coordinator
2000 Trident Way
San Diego, CA 92155

Thank you again for your concern in this matter, and for your assistance in upholding the honor of the US Navy SEAL Teams. If I can be of any further assistance to you in this matter, please contact me at your convenience.

Respectfully,  Don Shipley BUD/S 131, SEAL Team ONE, SEAL Team TWO.
Owner http://www.extremesealexperience.com/
CHARLES, LUIS CO 11/2007

Mr. Schaller,

I read with interest your 1 November 2007 story that was published in THE GAZETTE (Gazette.com), Colorado Springs, CO "Grandfather helps Air Force linebacker Charles cope".

http://www.gazette.com/sports/charles_29231___article.html/academy_army.html

In your story, you stated that Luis Charles, the grandfather of Nick Charles served several tours in Vietnam and that during one of these tours, he was captured by enemy forces.
 
Was there a mistake? Official Department of Defense records shows the only Charles that was captured and released during Vietnam was Norris Alphonzo Charles, who at the time of his capture was a US Navy Lieutenant Junior Grade (O2) Officer, not US Army. His home of record was Tampa, Florida, not Texas:   http://www.dtic.mil/dpmo/pmsea/files.htm  http://www.pownetwork.org/bios/c/c141.htm
 
Are you saying Norris Charles and Luis Charles are one and the same?
 
If the story is not true, will you be publishing a retract?
 
Thank you for your assistance.
 
LTC (Retired) M
US Army
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Grandfather helps Air Force linebacker Charles cope

November 1, 2007 - 11:49PM
 
...Every time doubts crept into Charles’ head, so would thoughts of his grandfather. Luis Charles, now 70, served in the Army for 23 years, including several tours in Vietnam. During one of those tours, he was captured by enemy forces.

....In the Army he served with the 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions and with a Special Forces unit when he was in Vietnam. His capture is something he does not talk about much....
Mr. Schaller....Yes, you can bet it is not true.  Every man captured (even if for only an hour or so) is listed.  Every unit commander was required to write After Action Reports.  If a man is missing from a unit, even for a short time, it is a serious matter.  Reporting a man missing after an action sets in motion a whole list of things, including notifying the man's family, notifying the service chain of command, assigning a CACO for the family, a Western Union Telegram to the family, service records entries, etc.  Talk to Mr. Greer at DPMO.  He can verify what I am telling you. 

Sincerely,

Mike McGrath

 

Cheek, Fred CA . Claims POW Deceased 01/99
Chellis, Gary Sandia Pk NM 06/2005 Claims to have been a Vietnam POW for five days until his escape from his captors. He claims to have been shot twice while being captured. Rumored to be receiving disability pay from Siemens due to the PTSD he suffers from because of his "capture." Claims that he had been on a secret mission and it was the Army's policy to keep such info out of the records - even the Purple Heart he earned on the mission.  .
Cheney, Gerry Huntsville, MO
LARGO, FL
10/2002 Claims joined USN 1960. Recruited into  Navy Intel from boot camp. 1963, SEAL training. COMAIRPAC 7th Fleet, special ops on Bon Homme Richard CVA 31. Received filed command as Navy LT. Awards - 2 Silver Stars, 2 Bronze Stars w/V, 3 Purple Hearts, POW Ribbon, service in Vietnam, Lifesaving, LeLass Honor Medal, Civilian Action Award,  National Defense, Vietnam Service with a Fleet Marine Device. Expert rifle/Pistol with E ribbons and 24 letters of commendations. PI in FL, St. Petersburg Police Depatment, Missouri Prison Guard, Deputy Sheriff of Randolph County for 20 years and 15 years with Dept of Justice. Wheel chair bound - Head Veteran Dancer (Native American Indian). Dob 12/26/42 (Indiana) .
Cheney, Kevin Newnan, GA 11/2006 Claims to be a Vietnam POW NOT to be confused with Kevin J Cheney, wife Kathy.
Christenberry, Dexter A Piney Flats, TN 09/2005
01/2007
http://www.tricities.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=TRI%2FMGArticle%2FTRI_BasicArticle&c=MGArticle&cid=1031785039433&path=/news/localnews&s

Hurricane Hero

Dexter Christenberry isn't giving money, clothes or water to Hurricane Katrina victims. He's driving entire homes to them: 200 campers with air conditioning, bathrooms and more....

The former prisoner of war was changed forever by what he saw along the coast this weekend....


ACTUAL

Enlisted in the Navy 26OCT62 and was released 19JUN64. He never rose above the grade of Airman Apprentice.  He was on the USS Ticonderoga from 16MAY63 thru 13DEC63, and then he was on the USS Saratoga until 20APR64. The last entry shows him stationed at the U.S. Naval Hospital, Pa on 19JUN64 when they discharged him.

Number 6 wife is divorcing him as of 01/2007

"Told stories of his valor and glory in Vietnam as a Navy Seal .... knew good and well that these stories were lies. (The POW story is a new one; I never heard that one before.) "
Christmas, James Seattle 06/2004 Claims POW captured and tortured.

Has alot of flash backs and can't sleep etc. He claims the Viet Nam guards hurt him really bad and that is why he cannot work.

Lots of his stories  -  and they are not the same on different days

CHRISTMAS JAMES JR AR E05 36K4O N

Name JAMES JR CHRISTMAS
Service ARMY
Service Component
Pay Grade E-5
Military Specialty 36K4O
Home of Record Unknown

36K
FIELD SWITCHBOARD OPERATOR
FIELD WIREMAN
MESSAGE CLK

He was in Nam Feb 68 to Feb 1970. Korea and Germany after that. He was a "wireman"
No Purple Heart, Silver Star, Bronze star etc. He was NOT wounded nor captured. Completed his tour, and went on for many more years in the service, not being discharged until 88.
Christopher, William Jr. . . Claims POW .
Churchill, Jim OH # Claims POW .

 C[2].

Next page

 

INTRODUCTION

CLAIMING VIETNAM PRISONER OF WAR:

V V A - Claims by members of  Vietnam Veterans of America

==================================
More Reported Claims:

Medal of Honor, Other than Vietnam POWs, Son Tay Raiders, DSC, DFC, Purple Heart, Silver Star, Bronze Star, Navy Cross, SEALS, Rangers, Pilots, Special Forces, Green Berets, Combat, Vietnam Helicopter Pilots, Flying Tigers, DOUBT EVERYTHING, Don't Encourage 

APOLOGIES AND CLARIFICATIONS

RE: ANY NAME ON THIS PAGE:  If anyone has viable proof of their captivity [or claims] which is accepted by the American Ax-POWs, NAM-POWs, DoD  and DMPO - PLEASE contact us immediately. We will take corrective action and work with them to be recognized for their sacrifice.

 

Home POW/MIA Name Index Bracelet History Remains Returned Yugoslavia Bios GALA
NETWORK History LOVELETTERS Index Return a Bracelet Statistics Gulf War, Michael Speicher Branson, MO
NETWORK Info Sources Heroes or Villains? Index What you can do  Russian Memoirs Pilots in Pajamas Links
Donations & Sponsorship Live Sighting Index Shopping Guide China & POWs N Vietnamese Interrogators Contacts
email us More than a Band of Metal.... POW  Remembrance Coin...  Order NOW

Hanoi Jane Fonda